In this Bar Rescue episode, Jon Taffer visits CJ’s Pub and Grill in Smithton, Illinois.
CJ’s Pub and Grill is owned by Jeremy.
He is an army vet who bought the bar in 2023.
Jeremy ran it full time with his wife Christy and veterans loved the bar.
Christy is a full-time Nurse and returned to work.
She now comes to the bar after work.
They have had a problem attracting a newer and younger crowd.
With all this, and the couple's lack of experience, the bar was suffering.
They were resistant to new ideas and change.
Jon arrives in the surveillance vehicle with expert mixologist Mia Mastroiani and expert chef Jennifer Murphy.
There they found out the bar had been open since 1947, and the exterior looks like it.
Inside, they see the kitchen has household equipment for cooking.
They have asked former NHL stars to go in as spies along with Jon.
They were greeted quickly and ordered food.
They do not have a drink menu or any specialty drinks.
After the order, Jon talked to the owners, telling them the menu was not inspiring.
Jon was enthusiastic about the history of the bar, telling the hockey stars what he knew.
Jon saw the bartender making the Old Fashioned but caught him mixing it with his fingers.
He confronted Jeremy with what he had seen and the fact that there were cooking tools in the bar.
The drinks arrive but they were tasted off and were too sweet.
Jon saw the bartender take a drink to the back and then bring it back out.
He inspected the room and saw the area was a walk-in.
The back area is in a state.
There is a premade margarita in a jug with mold on the floors and walls.
With this evidence, he confronted the owners and then shut down the bar service.
Jon thinks it is a health risk and can’t serve customers.
He lets all the customers know that they must stop drinking and leave.
The staff now need to clean up and remove the sources of the contamination.
The next day, they found out Jeremy had stayed all night to clean.
Jon comes in to meet with all the staff.
There are several new staff and the ones who have been there the longest say there was a lack of organization.
The bartender says that Jeremy drinks at work.
Christy confirms that it is affecting not only the business but the marriage.
Jeremy accepts he has a problem and has to make a change.
He is still in denial that he is the main problem of the bar.
Jon has a few choice words about this before he introduces his experts.
They did not see much the night before, so they go in to assess.
Jennifer sees that the kitchen is a mess of tools and packages on counters.
The walk-in has lots of issues with cross-contamination.
Sausages that were cooked over two weeks ago are still in storage.
They decide that the kitchen needs to be deep cleaned, decluttered and organized.
Mia wants to assess the staff and asks them to make an Old Fashioned.
This time they could mix properly but the drinks they made are still bad.
They are trained to make them correctly.
For the stress test, Jon has a table of customers start a timer to see when they get served.
The orders were taken on paper and given to Jeremy to input into the POS.
Then he goes into the kitchen to put pizzas in the oven.
The tickets in the kitchen are handwritten and the system ensures that the kitchen gets slammed.
In 15 minutes, only 8 people were served.
Jon found some misplaced tickets and no one knew who took them.
One table got nachos in 22 minutes.
However, they were actually supposed to go to another table that had ordered before them.
It was clear food and drinks were going to the wrong tables.
The night was a failure and Jon calls out Jeremy before shutting the stress test down.
The next day, the training continueds with Jennifer, who showed them how to carve sirloin strip.
They are taught to prep every part of it for sandwiches, steak, tacos and burgers so no part would go to waste.
Jon sits with the couple and tells them about all the improvements that would make the system easier.
This includes moving the pizza making to the kitchen and installing a better ticketing and POS system.
Jeremy finally agrees he is the problem for resisting small changes that would make the bar better.
A few days later, they were all gathered outside the bar for the unveiling.
Jon points out their biggest asset is the railroad attached to the bar that has such a rich history.
They unveil the bar, which has been renamed to Smithton Station, with a brand new sign.
The inside had been redone to look more upscale with a railroad theme.
There is a brand new bar was installed in another corner.
They have SkyTabs, POS printers in the bar and the kitchen.
There are new bar products, new rockless tables and new wall murals.
There is an overhauled plumbing system and a train station board for announcements.
Jon gives Jeremy advice that for the business to work, he has to stop drinking at the bar.
Jeremy gives his word that he will.
After setting up, customers were let in.
On relaunch, the orders come through.
The tables now have table numbers so drinks and food did not get lost.
Drinks are being made quickly (10 every 8 minutes).
The bar is almost fully served and in record time.
Jon, the experts and the owners are so happy with the difference in service.
What Happened Next at CJ’s Pub and Grill?
Six weeks later, the community was in love with the new look and theme of the bar.
Food costs had gone down and the kitchen was more efficient.
Due to Christy relocating for her day job, they decided to sell the bar.
They had also received offers to sell the bar following the rescue.
CJ’s Pub and Grill is closed.
They closed in September 2024, two months after the rescue.
The bar was bought by Terra and Dave.
They reopened and renamed the bar to The Roost Bar and Grill.
Click for more Bar Rescues
Previous episode - Calendar's Pizzeria
Next episode - The Fireplace


